In a maximum-security prison, I interviewed Jack Roche, Australia’s most notorious Al Qaeda inmate. I also met Jack Roche’s Indonesian wife Afifah who genuinely cared for him.
Roche had access to the highest echelons of Al Qaeda, including its fountainhead Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan. Roche described businessman turned terrorist Osama as a “very nice man.” Roche also met the then head of Al Qaeda’s military wing Abu Hafts, a former Egyptian policeman. Roche also met the then Al Qaeda’s head of intelligence wing Saif Al Adil, a former Egyptian Colonel. Saif is the current Al Qaeda Amir or leader living in Iran. In Pakistan, Roche met with 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohamed alias Mokhtar. He also met in Afghanistan other attackers such as Christian Ganczarski who bombed the Tunisian synagogue killing 21 people, mostly German tourists.
British-born Roche suffered from an alcohol problem. After leaving three wives and three children, he arrived in Australia from East Berlin, using his birth name, Paul Holland. An Australian taxi driver and a factory worker, he quit drinking after converting to Islam.
An active member of the Muslim community in Sydney, he was radicalised by lectures delivered in Australia by a visiting Indonesian cleric Abu Bakar Bashir. Afterwards, Roche joined an Al Qaeda-aligned Jemaah Islamiyah, that engaged in sectarian violence and terrorist attacks. Roche met the twin Indonesian brothers Abdulrahman and Abdulrahim Ayub - who headed the Australian branch of Jemaah Islamiyah.
After joining Jemaah Islamiyah (JI) in 1996, Roche played an important role in Mantiqi Four, its network on Australian soil. Roche met with Abdullah Sungkar, the founder of JI and his successor Abu Bakr Bashir who travelled frequently to Australia to indoctrinate and raise funds. In Malaysia, he met Hambali, both the operational leader of JI and Al Qaeda in Southeast Asia. In Banting, Malaysia, he met with Hambali and Ba’asyir who lived next door to each other.
In a notebook Roche maintained, he describes his meetings with al-Qaeda officials and Hambali - the mastermind of the Bali bombings - and how they wanted the problems in Palestine to “be submitted again in the minds of the people of the world”.[1]
In 2000, he travelled to Afghanistan, joined Al Qaeda, and received training in manufacturing improvised explosive devices in Kandahar. Roche’s handler Mokhtar gave him the Al Qaeda name “Abdulah” meaning the “servant of Allah”. Later Mokhtar assigned Hambali to handle Roche and they tasked him from February 15 and May 26, 2000 to build a “white Australian” cell to mount attacks on Australian soil during the Sydney Olympics.
Al-Qaeda planned to train three to four white Australian Muslims to undertake firearms and explosives training in Afghanistan. Roche noted, “The main objective here is that this operation will not only be done once but issuing targets and disappear - in the future we will do something again and disappear…Their decision is two important targets in Australia - Israel embassy and/or Jews named Joe Gutnick. I also need to find other Jewish targets - for example when there is a meeting of a lot of Jewish, etc.”[2]
When Roche’s house in Perth was searched in 2002, the Australian authorities found two sets of model rocket igniters and a computer printout referring to Mr Gutnick. The igniters for model rockets in conjunction with a mobile phone could have been remote triggers for a bomb. Roche conducted surveillance and filmed the Israeli embassy in Canberra and the Israeli consulate in Sydney. In his possession was a video of the Israeli Embassy shot by him in November 2002.
After Al Qaeda appointed Roche to direct operations, there was a dispute between Hambali and JI leaders the Ayub brothers in Australia. Roche’s heart was neither with the leadership of Al Qaeda nor Jemaah Islamiyah. As such, he was in two minds. Keen to become an informant, Roche approached the US consulate in Sydney and upon their recommendation the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO). However, he claimed they were not interested in him or his information.
Throughout his prison life, Roche cooperated with the Australian, American, European and other governments. When I interviewed him, Roche was very cooperative. He spoke of the training he received in Afghanistan, the plans to attack the Israeli embassy in Canberra and Israeli Consulate in Sydney, Australia, and other Al Qaeda operations including the plot to hit Sydney Olympics. He was considered dangerous as he wanted to attack aviation both American and Israeli. Roche was tasked by Al Qaeda to target Melbourne businessman and former Melbourne Football Club president Joe Gutnick alias Diamond because of his support for former Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
After he was arrested, Roche cooperated with the Australian authorities and their counterparts. Found guilty of conspiring to blow up the Israeli embassy, R v Roche [2005] WASCA 4 note that the conviction was under pre-2002 legislation (Crimes Act s.86, as at 2000) and not under terrorism legislation. As he cooperated, instead of sentencing him to 25 years imprisonment, Roche only served four and half of the nine years. Released in 2007, he shared details about Al Qaeda and Jemaah Islamiyah including the network on Australian soil. Roche wanted to be significant! A Muslim convert, Roche loved the exciting and the dangerous life he led.
One of Australia’s most accomplished journalists Natalie O’Brien wrote, “Australia’s biggest intelligence failure pre 9/11 went on to become a highly valuable asset for the FBI. They knew his worth and paid him handsomely to give up everything he knew about the Al Qaeda leadership and its Indonesian affiliate Jemaah Islamiyah, the group behind the Bali bombings. But it has taken so long to get the accused Bali mastermind Hambali and accused 9/11 architect, Khaled Sheikh Mohomed, to trial that Jack Roche can no longer testify.”[3]
“That kind of money being paid to him meant they wanted him to testify in trials,” Professor Gunaratna said.
“They looked after him. They paid him that money for him to tell the truth.
“The FBI is a very professional organisation and they have a lot of experience working with people like this. The FBI did not do anything wrong by paying him. They did not influence him by making the payments they just wanted him to tell the truth.”
Professor Gunaratna said he had also interviewed Roche while he was in Hakea prison in Perth and had extensive communications with him and found that “he did not lie. He always told the truth.”
Roche represented one of Australia’s biggest intelligence failures prior to 9/11.
Read the full article about Jack Roche, the first convicted terrorist in Australia, in this link or by clicking on the image below.
---
Prof Rohan Gunaratna is Professor of Security Studies at the Nanyang Technological University and the founder of its International Centre for Political Violence and Terrorism Research in Singapore. He is the Author of Inside Al Qaeda: Global Network of Terror, published by Columbia University Press.
[1] https://www.theage.com.au/national/australian-jews-were-al-qaeda-targets-20040520-gdxvs9.html
[2] https://www.theage.com.au/national/australian-jews-were-al-qaeda-targets-20040520-gdxvs9.html
[3] https://thenightly.com.au/australia/jack-roche-convicted-australian-terrorist-recruited-by-fbi-for-us400000-c-22869881


